10 Worst Dog Breeds For First-Time Owners
WorldAnimalFoundation.org is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn More
There’s no denying that dogs hold a special place in our hearts. While we might have different opinions on the best size or temperament for a furry friend, we can all agree that dogs are wonderful additions to any household.
If you’re considering getting a dog, it’s crucial to find one that matches your lifestyle and personality. Not all breeds are the same; some require more care, exercise, or grooming, while others may be more suitable for families with children.
Dogs bring immense joy and companionship, but picking the right breed is vital, especially for first-time owners. By learning about the breeds that might be more demanding, you can make a well-informed decision and ensure a happy, fulfilling relationship with your new canine companion.
Choosing a dog based solely on their appearance or energy level can be tempting, but it’s essential to consider their needs and how they fit with your daily life. This guide will help you understand ten breeds that might be more difficult for first-time owners to handle. Being aware of the potential challenges can help you prepare better.
Worst Dog Breeds for First-time Owners
1. Skye Terrier
The Skye Terrier, originating from the Isle of Skye in Scotland, is known for being brave, loyal, and intelligent. Despite its playful and loving nature, the Skye Terrier might not be the best choice for first-time dog owners.
These dogs are very protective and can be wary of strangers. Some Skye Terriers may even resort to biting if they feel threatened. Early socialization is crucial to prevent them from becoming overly fearful or aggressive toward unfamiliar people. Skye Terriers crave a lot of attention and affection from their family. They thrive on being close to their loved ones and can become unhappy if left alone for long periods.
WebMD notes that Skye Terriers can be quite stubborn and strong-willed. While they respond well to positive training methods, their independent nature can be challenging for new dog owners who might not have experience with persistent training.
Their stubbornness and potential for conflict with other dogs make them less suitable for families with very young children. They might not tolerate rough handling or the unpredictable behavior of small kids. Skye Terriers can develop problem barking, which can be a nuisance, especially for apartment dwellers. This behavior can be difficult for first-time owners to manage without proper training.
2. German Shepherds
The German Shepherd Dog is known for its loyalty, intelligence, and bravery, making it an impressive yet challenging pet for families. Originally bred for herding, German Shepherds have strong protective instincts that can lead to aggression if they sense a threat to their family. This trait requires an owner who is patient and capable of effectively guiding and controlling their behavior.
German Shepherds need a lot of mental stimulation and exercise to stay happy, which can take up a significant amount of time. Neglecting their exercise needs can lead to destructive behaviors and health issues. Additionally, they shed heavily, which can be a hassle for first-time dog owners who are not used to managing a lot of dog hair in their home.
Training a German Shepherd also requires a considerable investment of time and effort. For those unfamiliar with dog training or unable to dedicate the necessary time, this breed may not be the best choice. Their size can make managing them in public spaces more challenging, as ensuring they are well-behaved and controlled is crucial.
German Shepherds are also prone to several health issues, including hip dysplasia, elbow dysplasia, and degenerative myelopathy. These conditions can cause pain, mobility problems, and a reduced quality of life, often requiring extensive and potentially expensive veterinary care.
3. Treeing Walker Coonhound
Before adopting a Treeing Walker Coonhound, there are several important factors to consider. These dogs can be challenging to train, especially for those unfamiliar with the breed. While they are eager to please, they also possess a stubborn and independent streak that can make training difficult. Coonhounds are known for being loud, and unless you live far from neighbors, they will definitely hear your Coonhound when he gets excited about finding a good scent.
According to AKC, if you have other small, furry pets like cats, hamsters, or rabbits, a Treeing Walker Coonhound may not be the best choice. These hounds have a high prey drive and might see your other animals as prey. They should always be on a leash during walks and hikes, as their instinct to pursue interesting scents can be overwhelming.
Treeing Walker Coonhounds are also a high-energy breed that loves to run and exercise. They make excellent companions for running or hiking but might be too demanding for someone new to dog ownership. Their need for extensive physical activity and their loud, vocal nature can be overwhelming for first-time dog owners.
4. Dobermans
The Doberman might not be the best fit for a first-time pet owner. Although they are highly intelligent and quick learners, they need owners who are committed to working with them and stimulating their intellect. Dobermans are not content to sit around all day with nothing to do; they thrive on activity and being involved in your daily life.
Dobermans can be quite stubborn, and they require a lot of your time and presence. They form strong bonds with their owners and can develop separation anxiety if left alone for too long. This anxiety can manifest even before you leave the house, as your dog may sense that they will be left alone. Dogs with separation anxiety often become destructive.
Dobbies may exhibit aggressive behaviors or try to dominate other dogs of the same sex. However, some Dobermans do live happily with other dogs of the same sex in the home.
While Dobermans can make excellent family pets, their large size and strong build can be challenging for first-time dog owners to manage. Additionally, despite their beauty and intelligence, Dobermans are prone to several health issues. They can develop a life-threatening condition known as bloat, and hip dysplasia is also common in the breed.
5. Cane Corso
While these majestic creatures captivate with their muscular build and noble demeanor, they’re not the perfect fit for first-time dog owners. Cane Corsos are known for their assertive nature and require an owner who can confidently take charge. If you’re not someone who exudes leadership and a self-assertive personality, managing a Cane Corso could prove to be quite challenging.
These dogs are incredibly smart and will continuously test boundaries. Cane Corsos thrive under consistent and firm leadership. They possess a strong protective instinct, which, if not properly managed, can lead to problematic behaviors. Without rigorous supervision and a secure environment, a Cane Corso’s protective nature might manifest as aggression towards strangers or other animals.
Their large size alone means they must be well-behaved and obedient for the safety of themselves and others. Cane Corsos are working dogs at heart and need a job or purpose to stay mentally and physically stimulated. According to Forbes, Cane Corsos tend to be willful and socially dominant. As an intelligent and driven breed, Cane Corsos become easily bored. Without sufficient mental and physical stimulation, they can develop destructive behaviors.
6. Border Collies
Border Collies are known for their exceptional intelligence and quick learning abilities, making them easy to train. However, their high energy levels and sharp minds might not be ideal for first-time dog owners.
Originating as herding dogs, Border Collies have a restless nature and a constant need to be active, both mentally and physically. This can make them challenging to keep up with, as they require constant engagement and stimulation.
These dogs are very social and need a lot of attention from their owners. Without sufficient mental and physical activities, they can become destructive and develop behavioral issues. Border Collies can chew, dig, or bark excessively if they are bored or left alone for too long.
According to PetMD, they also have a natural herding instinct, often nipping at the legs of fast-moving objects, which can include children. This behavior can be problematic, especially in households with young kids.
7. Siberian Husky
Siberian Huskies, known for their playful and mischievous nature, require a significant amount of physical exercise and mental stimulation to stay happy. For first-time owners, Huskies might not be the best choice due to their considerable exercise needs and inherent stubbornness. These dogs are extremely active and can become destructive if not properly exercised and mentally engaged. Their temperament can be unpredictable, adding another layer of difficulty for new dog owners.
Unlike breeds that have a strong desire to please, Huskies have a natural inclination towards independence. This trait, reflecting their history as endurance sled dogs, makes them challenging to train for those new to dog ownership.
According to the PDSA, Huskies do not cope well on their own and ideally need a home where someone is around all the time to keep them company. They are prone to separation anxiety and may struggle even with short periods of being left alone.
Additionally, Huskies shed a lot. Bred for cold and snowy climates, they have a thick double coat and they shed more than the average dog throughout the year. This can be particularly challenging for first-time dog owners who are not prepared for the constant grooming and cleaning up of dog hair.
8. French Bulldogs
While French Bulldogs are undeniably charming and lovable, they might not tick all the boxes for first-time dog owners. French Bulldogs are known for forming strong bonds with their owners, and as a result, they may experience separation anxiety when left alone. This can lead to excessive barking, destructive behavior, or signs of distress.
Due to their short snouts and distinctive flat facial features, French Bulldogs can be noisy companions. They are known for their snorting and snuffling sounds. While these unique sounds are part of their charm, they may not be suitable for individuals who prefer a quieter living environment.
According to PETA, French Bulldogs tend to suffer from various health issues, resulting in potentially expensive medical bills. They are prone to ear infections, diarrhea, pinkeye, skin fold dermatitis, and brachycephalic obstructive airway syndrome, often requiring surgery. These health problems can demand a lot of time, attention, and financial resources from their owners.
French Bulldogs are also known for their higher cost compared to many other dog breeds. In fact, they are one of the most expensive dogs in the world.
9. Rottweilers
The Rottweiler is a beautiful breed, but it is not suitable for everyone. Rottweilers should not be chosen by people who simply want a dog to hang around the house and yard. These working dogs thrive when they have interesting tasks and activities to engage in. Rottweilers are not always recommended for first-time owners due to their large size and strength, which necessitate proper training and handling.
According to Hill’s Pet, most Rottweilers are good with other pets in their own family, but some can show predatory behavior toward cats, and many Rottweilers can be aggressive toward other dogs of the same sex.
The best Rottweilers are versatile working dogs capable of learning a great deal, but they are not easy to raise and train. These dogs will test their owners to prove they can make them obey. Aggression can be an issue, and due to their size and strength, Rottweilers can inflict severe damage. If left to their own devices, they can become nuisance barkers or diggers, and their size means they are capable of causing significant destruction.
Despite having short hair, Rottweilers shed more than one might expect, often on the high side of average.
10. Australian Shepherds
This high-energy, high-maintenance breed can be much more work than your average dog. Australian Shepherds, often called Aussies, require plenty of physical activity and mental stimulation to stay content. If you are a first-time dog owner, an Aussie may not be the best fit for you. Bored Australian Shepherds express their frustration through barking and destructive chewing, leading to hyperactivity and excessive noise. They can also become destructive around the house if their energy needs aren’t met.
Due to their herding instincts, Aussies can’t resist chasing anything that moves quickly, which can be problematic if you are new to dog training. Their natural instinct to herd can sometimes extend to other pets or even their humans, which may not be ideal in a household setting.
While their coats are beautiful, Australian Shepherds shed a lot. Regular grooming is necessary to manage the shedding, which can be more demanding than some owners are prepared for. Taking care of an Australian Shepherd requires a significant amount of attention and space for them to burn off their energy. They are not a breed that can be left alone for long periods or kept in confined spaces without sufficient exercise.
Conclusion
While dogs bring immense joy and companionship, not every dog breed is suitable for first-time pet parents. Breeds like the Border Collie, Pit bull, and Australian Cattle Dog, despite their intelligence and loyalty, require significant time, training, and mental stimulation that can be overwhelming for new owners. These high-energy breeds, like Australian Cattle dogs, along with others such as the Australian Shepherd, are best suited for experienced owners who can meet their demanding needs.
Choosing the right dog breed is crucial for a positive pet ownership experience. First-time pet parents should consider breeds that are more adaptable and easier to manage. By doing thorough research and understanding the specific requirements of different breeds, new owners can ensure a harmonious and fulfilling relationship with their furry companions.
